ProofAtlas research case study

Starting frontier2013 lower bound: 0.232239AI-developed Lean-checked candidateLower bound: 0.23743658226923856768
Evidence and status →

Convex geometry · formalization overview

Moser's Convex Worm Mixed-Area Lower Bound

Four Lean-checked pointwise area inequalities cover finite polygonal worms and all unit worms, with direct motions or reflections allowed. Their strict rational corollaries give the lower bound 0.23743658226923856768; the exact optimum remains open.

Scope: Every compact convex cover universal for finite polygonal worms or for all unit worms has area strictly greater than 0.23743658226923856768, both with direct motions and when reflections are allowed.

Lean checkedRecorded build passed
Unfinished proof stepsNone
PublicationReview pending
Moser worm lower-bound statement mapFour exact Lean theorem pairs bound the area of each convex cover universal for finite polygonal worms or all unit worms, with direct motions or reflections allowed.
Exact scope: Every compact convex cover universal for finite polygonal worms or for all unit worms has area strictly greater than 0.23743658226923856768, both with direct motions and when reflections are allowed.

Main theorem

Direct-Motion Universal Worm Lower Bound

Four Lean-checked pointwise area inequalities cover finite polygonal worms and all unit worms, with direct motions or reflections allowed. Their strict rational corollaries give the lower bound 0.23743658226923856768; the exact optimum remains open.

The theorem dossier brings together the expanded exact proposition, complete checked source, and checker evidence.

Lean checkedRecorded build passedUnfinished proof stepsNonePublication review pendingReview is separate from the Lean check
Warm ivory ProofAtlas metadata cover for A Mixed-Area Lower Bound for Moser's Convex Worm Problem by Lech Mazur, showing four identical convex covers with one sample unit curve inside each and the lower bound 0.23743658226923856768.

Companion research paper

A Mixed-Area Lower Bound for Moser's Convex Worm Problem

The September 2 paper proves that both the direct and reflection-allowed convex-worm covering infima exceed 0.23743658226923856768, improving the prior 0.232239 lower bound. The exact optimum remains open. A separate Lean development checks stronger pointwise versions for each universal convex cover.

Author-authorized early release. This fixed paper package first appeared while independent presentation review was pending; hosting it does not mark the Lean result accepted.

Paper, rights, and source relationship

Hosting authorized by the rightsholder. ProofAtlas metadata cover; not a reproduction of a paper page or part of the proof.

Lech Mazur, “A Mixed-Area Lower Bound for Moser's Convex Worm Problem,” September 2, 2026.

  • The four Lean endpoints are pointwise inequalities for each universal convex cover. The paper separately takes infima to state bounds for M_+ and M_±; that infimum packaging is not a Lean declaration in this release.
  • The source release ledger reports successful targeted checks, aggregate replay, no admissions, and the standard foundation closure propext, Classical.choice, and Quot.sound. ProofAtlas accepted-result status remains separate because the retained evidence is not the complete hash-bound build transcript required by the current contract.
  • The paper's adversarial audit predates the final 21:22 build. Its mathematical and expository findings F2–F5 are repaired in the matching final TeX; F1 is resolved by the permanent ProofAtlas routes published with this package.
  • Neither the paper nor the Lean result determines the exact optimal cover, establishes optimality of the lower bound, or closes Moser's convex worm problem.

Scope limits

What this formalization does not claim

Continue the mathematics

Open questions and extensions

Use the pinned Lean source to inspect the mixed-support packing theorem, calibrated angular partitions, finite midpoint worms, and the four pointwise endpoints. Further work can improve the bound or narrow the upper bound, but must preserve the exact motion mode, worm class, and distinction between pointwise cover inequalities and infimum packaging.

What the source ZIP contains

The ZIP contains the checked first-party Lean import closure, exact statements and boundaries, license, notice, evidence, source-footprint manifest, and continuation data. Mathlib and other third-party dependencies are not bundled.

Proof and source

What is checked—and how much source supports it

Browse the counted source
Declarations covered by evidence
8
First-party Lean files
72
Lean source lines
16,269
Main recorded file
71 lines
How the source is counted

Line counts exclude blank lines; comments and documentation count. The total is the deduplicated, commit-pinned first-party Lean import closure; Mathlib and other third-party dependencies are excluded. Declaration count means names covered by the artifact's recorded evidence, not every declaration in the source. Source footprint is not a difficulty or proof-quality score.

Formal theorem review status — 4 questions open

Independent review

Four review questions remain open

Lean has checked the exact source, but ProofAtlas has not accepted this result. Independent AI, human, or mixed reviewers may examine the build evidence, statement alignment, result boundary, and public wording. Review does not replace Lean's check or broaden the theorem.

Review 1

Formal evidence

An independent reviewer must inspect the recorded build, declarations, unfinished-proof-step check, and disclosed foundations.

Review 2

Statement alignment

The formal declaration must be reviewed against the theorem wording and its exact variant.

Review 3

Result boundary

The limits must be checked so the page cannot imply a broader theorem.

Review 4

Public wording

The explanation, infographic labels, and source presentation need independent review.

Source

Canonical source

The permanent source link and downloadable files must be approved for public citation.

Final record

Accepted result

After the four reviews and source route are ready, an accepted-result record must bind them to this exact formalization.

Credit for this release

Contributors and roles

Authorship and other contributions are recorded separately for this version.

Authorship

Paper author
Lech Mazur

Contributions

  • Direct contributionOpenAI Codex, OpenAI GPT-5.6 Pro

    OpenAI GPT-5.6 Pro and OpenAI Codex have source-reported roles in mathematical exploration, proof development, computational testing, adversarial auditing, formalization, and exposition.

    • Computation
    • Exposition
    • Formalization
    • Gap or error discovery
    • Proof strategy
  • Direct contributionLech Mazur

    Lech Mazur is the paper author and accountable editor and directed the AI-assisted research, verification process, output selection, and reconciliation.

    • Exposition
    • Proof strategy
    • Research direction

Citation

Cite this release

Use the version-specific citation so the authorship, scope, and public record remain attached.

Release history

Versions and public record

Release
Paper release
Version
public version of September 2, 2026
Published
Canonical page
Open canonical page
Earlier release
credit.release.moser-worm-mixed-area-lower-bound.v001

Release chronology

This version is part of the release history. No independent external timestamp is claimed.

Scope of this release

  • No accepted-result record exists for the Moser worm artifacts in this snapshot.
  • No independent external priority anchor, specialist review, or independent statement-alignment review is recorded.
  • The paper's infimum notation is not a Lean declaration in this release; the checked endpoints are stronger pointwise cover inequalities.
  • The paper, bundle, supplied infographic, and ProofAtlas covers are authorized for ProofAtlas distribution but have no general open-content license.
  • The result improves a lower bound and does not determine the optimal cover or solve Moser's convex worm problem.

Expanded visual

Open original image