Work directly with 1-𝔲=ηZ^MW^N and seek a theorem specialized to a norm-one element in a pure cubic field, such as a nondegenerate conjugate recurrence or primitive positive valuation incompatible with both exponent colours.
Route status · Active routeNumber theory · exponential Diophantine equations · arithmetic geometry
Pillai's Conjecture
Collaboration betaThe v8 source keeps Pillai's fixed-gap conjecture open. It replaces the stale affine-ray/Kummer frontier with a maximal-exponent cubic reduction, all-fixed-parameter denominator and coefficient-primitivity theorems, exact balanced and Cardano saturation, and a two-colour norm-one S-unit interface of height 2 log Y+o(log Y). The terminal arithmetic theorem is missing. Five live routes, six sufficient blockers, seven work orders, and ten compact no-revisit findings define the current source-reported frontier. The supporting materials have not been independently checked and are not independent evidence.

Research problem
Exact mathematical statement
Fix an integer . Pillai's conjecture asks whether the equation
has only finitely many tuples of integers with and . Swapping the two perfect powers replaces by , so the two signs are treated symmetrically. The selected v8 source develops a maximal-exponent cubic reduction and a two-colour norm-one S-unit program; the terminal arithmetic theorem remains open.
Problem infographic
Problem at a glance

Current mathematical picture
Where work on Pillai's Conjecture stands
The v8 source keeps Pillai's fixed-gap conjecture open. It replaces the stale affine-ray/Kummer frontier with a maximal-exponent cubic reduction, all-fixed-parameter denominator and coefficient-primitivity theorems, exact balanced and Cardano saturation, and a two-colour norm-one S-unit interface of height 2 log Y+o(log Y). The terminal arithmetic theorem is missing. Five live routes, six sufficient blockers, seven work orders, and ten compact no-revisit findings define the current source-reported frontier. The supporting materials have not been independently checked and are not independent evidence.
Along a hypothetical infinite fixed-gap counterfamily with fixed k at least two, each numerical perfect power has a unique maximal-exponent representation; after discarding bounded values and using the source's fixed-prime exclusion, the exponents and bases are pairwise coprime in the stated senses.
Evidence posture · Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteProve that for all sufficiently large coprime M,N the special norm-one element has a prime ideal outside S with a positive valuation of 1-𝔲 divisible by neither M nor N.
Task status · Ready to work onThe v8 source reports a maximal-exponent cubic reduction, fixed-parameter denominator and primitivity results, saturation of several older routes, and a two-colour norm-one interface while leaving the terminal theorem open.
Retained source recordWork mapped so far
Pillai's Conjecture in numbers
- Argument development
- 2,827 · 84%
- Explored or eliminated routes
- 107 · 3%
- Computational analysis
- 38 · 1%
- Open obligations
- 194 · 6%
- Definitions and setup
- 209 · 6%
How this is measured
This measures retained mathematical investigation, not proximity to a proof. Code, data, logs, repeated text, operational instructions, and generated presentation copy are excluded.
Recommended next task
B1 primitive valuation outside the kernel
Prove that for all sufficiently large coprime M,N the special norm-one element has a prime ideal outside S with a positive valuation of 1-𝔲 divisible by neither M nor N.
Suggested move: Seek a primitive-divisor or valuation-one theorem specialized to the exact two-colour pure-cubic norm-one family.
What would count as progress
- Produce a prime ideal 𝔭 outside S
- Prove v_𝔭(1-𝔲)>0
- Prove neither M nor N divides that valuation
Argument map and routes
How the current approaches connect
Claims, reductions, open questions, active routes, and narrowed alternatives in one mathematical map.
Visible working map
Research route map
Selected claims, active routes, useful failures, and open questions from the current research map. Arrows appear only for explicitly recorded relationships.
Scroll horizontally to explore the route
Working overview, not proof. The map shows selected recorded relationships; more nodes or edges do not establish correctness or completion.
Work directly with 1-𝔲=ηZ^MW^N and seek a theorem specialized to a norm-one element in a pure cubic field, such as a nondegenerate conjugate recurrence or primitive positive valuation incompatible with both exponent colours.
Route status · Active routeExploit both perfect-power factor identities on the Mordell curve; a useful theorem must retain them and obtain polynomial dependence on rad(g) or AB.
Route status · Active routeUse the exact special residue and both high-power twists to produce a forbidden short multiplier; the companion cubic congruences themselves add no information.
Route status · Active routeSeek a Frey representation or modular obstruction from the fixed-gap equation, pure cubic norm equation, or two-colour identity, and audit conductor growth before large computations.
Route status · Active routeFactor (ξ) and (1-𝔲) in the pure cubic field while keeping explicit discriminant, regulator, class-group, and support dependence; do not replace ideal powers by element powers without class-group control.
Route status · Active routeExplored alternatives
Other routes
The second audit withdraws that inference and retains only the genus, discriminant, nodal-thickness, and residual-conductor statement. Use the Frey-Jacobian conductor theorem only, pending a separately proved decomposition or residual-image theorem.
Route status · Useful but insufficientThe current work's Sylow-rank obstruction rules out that direct containment; only a boundary/Prym split across two reflection factors remains supported. Construct two generic normal functions whose complementary boundary classes recover the two Kummer halves and then prove an arithmetic residual-image restriction.
Route status · Useful but insufficientThe source separately requires the original and swapped fixed-field ray quotients to be compared in one normal closure or through their Artin conductors, seeking a crossed-exponent reciprocity relation that makes the two affine constituents incompatible.
Route status · Route held in reserveBrowse 1 more explored route
The source separately requires the degree-prime transvection from DEG-BLOW-01 to enter the residual-image analysis, followed by classification of every reducible case with its local characters and fixed conductor support before automorphy or level lowering.
Route status · Route held in reserveRoute statements and reductions
Statements the next route can inspect and build on
If a companion column has determinant Δ=Y^{o(1)} and 0<|N_c|≤Y, the source proves |N_c|=Y^{1-o(1)}.
Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteFor the source's integer background Xn−Ym=1 and any integer companion column (M_c,N_c)∈ℤ², set Δ=XN_c−YM_c and h=M_cn−N_cm; then M_c=mΔ+Xh and N_c=nΔ+Yh, with the stated exact congruence and valuation consequences.
Source-reported route statementAfter substituting the exact companion parametrization, the two companion cubic congruences reduce to the adjacent congruences multiplied by Δ^3, so they provide no independent CRT phase.
Source-reported route statementFor H=𝔄^2-k𝔅 and the source's Cardano factors 𝕌,𝕍, the exact identities H=gXY, 𝕌=gγY^3, 𝕍=gαX^3, 𝕌𝕍=H^3, and 𝕍-𝕌=kg hold, yielding the stated toric coefficient ring after inverting fixed 2k.
Source-reported route statementFor a nonzero homogeneous Cardano section F of degree D with v_X(F)≥r and v_Y(F)≥s, the source proves first local weight ν(F)≤D-r-s; hence fixed-degree universal interpolation cannot save a fixed power beyond its visible divisor.
Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteWith τ^3=α^2γ, K=Q(τ), ξ=αX−τY, 𝔲=ξ^3/(α^2k), and η=3τξ/(kα^{j_M+1}γ^{j_N}), the source proves N(𝔲)=1 and 1−𝔲=ηZ^MW^N. For every prime ideal outside S, where S consists of the prime ideals above 3kαγ, η has valuation zero and every positive valuation of 1−𝔲 is an M-multiple or an N-multiple according to two disjoint rational supports: gcd(A,B)=1, supp(Z)=supp(A), and supp(W)=supp(B).
Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteFor the special norm-one element 𝔲, the source proves h(𝔲)=2 log Y+o(log Y), records sublinear field discriminant and logarithmic radical, and warns that generic S-unit estimates may lose force through moving regulator, class-group, or coefficient-height dependence.
Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteNo terminal contradiction is proved. Completion requires a new arithmetic theorem using both unbounded exponent colours simultaneously—such as a primitive positive valuation, support-sensitive height collapse, special Cardano height bound, forbidden additive rotation, or controlled-level two-exponent modular obstruction—with sufficiently uniform dependence on moving data.
Source-reported route statement · dependencies incompleteMore ways to contribute
Open questions
Additional prepared tasks for exploring this research frontier.
Prove that for all sufficiently large coprime M,N the special norm-one element has a prime ideal outside S with a positive valuation of 1-𝔲 divisible by neither M nor N.
Suggested move: Seek a primitive-divisor or valuation-one theorem specialized to the exact two-colour pure-cubic norm-one family.Study ideal quotients that cancel (η) outside the kernel without choosing generators and test whether class-group powers or conjugate ideal ratios yield a recurrence with incompatible new-prime multiplicities.
Suggested move: Track discriminant, class-number, and regulator dependence before principalizing.Translate every proposed moving-field, primitive-divisor, modular, or height theorem into polynomially effective dependence on all data that are only subpower in Y.
Suggested move: Record dependence on regulator, class number, coefficient height, and support size before treating an imported theorem as live.Prove a bound Y≪_k rad(g)^C for the Cardano points satisfying both high-power factor identities.
Suggested move: Use both perfect-power Cardano factors; do not discard them through a generic Mordell estimate.Produce a fixed ε>0 and a nonzero subpower multiplier Δ such that ||nΔ/Y||≤Y^{-ε} using the special residue and high-power twists.
Suggested move: Exploit n≡k^{-1}αX^2 mod Y together with both high-power twists; ordinary Dirichlet approximation is insufficient.Construct a Frey object seeing both moving exponents with level controlled by kαγ and incompatible local behavior, rather than conductor growth through all primes of AB.
Suggested move: Audit the candidate object's conductor growth and local minimality before any large computation.Use the simultaneous Mordell equation and both perfect-power factor identities, or the equivalent Belyi identity, to seek a polynomial height bound.
Suggested move: Audit factor gcds and ideal-class control before invoking logarithmic forms.Seek a multiplicative-subgroup, exponential-sum, or sparse-orbit result for the structured residue n/Y modulo the moving powerful modulus that produces a forbidden subpower multiplier.
Suggested move: Work with the exact high-power congruence; average equidistribution is insufficient.Study ξ_i/ξ_j and 1-(ξ_i/ξ_j)^3 to determine whether they form a nondegenerate binary or ternary recurrence after kernel units are removed.
Suggested move: First prove or refute genuine nondegeneracy, then seek valuation incompatibility with both exponent colours.Search primary literature for primitive-divisor and valuation-one theorems over number fields and record exact dependence on the moving field, discriminant, regulator, initial term, and index.
Suggested move: Reject fixed-sequence uniformity that does not remain uniform when both the sequence and field move.Identify a curve or representation seeing both M and N, determine whether its conductor avoids all primes of AB, test level lowering at both supports, and check incompatibility of the two local conditions.
Suggested move: Abort the modular route early if conductor growth loses the exponent information.In the special degree-three family, prove that sublinear field discriminant, sublinear logarithmic radical, and two disjoint positive multiplicity colours force h(𝔲)=o(log Y).
Suggested move: Control the dependence on η, the moving regulator, and the class group instead of applying a generic S-unit bound.Independently reconstruct T-PAIR-PRIMITIVITY and T-CARDANO-SATURATION before relying on either in a terminal proof.
Suggested move: Recheck rational-section denominator clearing, fixed-shear signs, toric monomial filtration, and cusp injectivity independently.Sourced mathematical context
The known mathematical landscape
What the literature has established
Selected external milestones in reverse chronological order, with their evidence posture.
PreprintBennett and Siksek develop explicit Diophantine, modular, and computational methods for restricted prime-power-gap equations and solve specified families.[3] Peer reviewedDietmann and Elsholtz describe the fixed-gap assertion for pure powers as widely open while using it as context for a separate Hilbert-cube problem.[2] Peer reviewedShorey records the generalized equation a x^m - b y^n = k and Pillai's conjecture that it has finitely many solutions under the stated exponent conditions.[1]
Mathematical neighborhood
Related results and reusable starting points
Shorey's displayed formulation permits fixed positive coefficients a and b, so the pure-power difference x^m-y^n=k is its coefficient-one specialization.
[1]Hilbert cubes in the set of pure powers are related through repeated bounded gaps, but their finite-dimensionality does not prove the full fixed-gap conjecture.
[2]Restricted equations with a square on one side and a difference supported on prescribed prime powers can be explicitly determined in many cases; these are narrower families than the unrestricted fixed-k statement.
[3]Formal and computational footholds
Existing statements, libraries, computations, and datasets that can shorten the next serious attempt.
- computation · not independently reproducedRestricted prime-power-gap calculations
The preprint reports explicit determination of specified families using Diophantine approximation, modular methods, and equation-solving computations; this metadata lane did not reproduce them.
[3]
Formalization opportunities
Lean work can make these reusable foundations precise without being presented as a proof of the core problem.
- Formalization targetFormalize the exact v8 companion parametrization, Cardano saturation, two-colour norm-one S-unit identity, and the remaining support-sensitive terminal arithmetic interface; these remain source-reported until independently checked.
Later mathematical changes
What changed after the initial research map
Later recorded revisions that changed the mathematics, without inventing a date or an AI attribution.
Changed the research frontierLater mathematical revision
Changed the research frontierLater mathematical revision
The initial argument structure appears separately. Uploads, model runs, and presentation changes do not count as mathematical updates.
Research-record corrections
What changed in the research record
These notes describe corrections to cited passages, highlighted tasks, or connections between claims. The mathematical claims and their status did not change.
Corrected the research recordCorrection note
The initial argument structure appears separately. Uploads, model runs, and presentation changes do not count as mathematical updates.
Detailed research inventory
Claims, milestones, and routes in the current map
This inventory covers all currently cataloged mathematical statements in the research notes.
- negative result
3 of 24 3 - theorem candidate
2 of 24 2 - reduction
3 of 24 3 - lemma
16 of 24 16
Pillai v8 recorded theorem and frontier mapThe v8 active projection records the maximal-exponent and cubic reductions, all fixed-parameter denominator and primitivity results, exact balanced and Cardano saturation, the two-colour norm-one interface, the missing terminal theorem, six blockers, five live routes, seven work orders, and ten compact no-revisit findings. All statuses remain source-reported and provisional.70 displayed rows · 5 routes included
- retained route statementPillai fixed-gap finiteness target
- retained route statementT-CANONICAL maximal-exponent reductionintermediate
- retained route statementEXT-BU bounded-support exclusionintermediate
- retained route statementEXT-W2 Baker product windowintermediate
- retained route statementT-KERNEL fixed-r kernel growthintermediate
- retained route statementT-CUBIC determinant-one transformed cubicintermediate
- retained route statementT-TWIST exact high-power twistsintermediate
- retained route statementT-ROOT ordered-root modelintermediate
- retained route statementT-TRIANGLE ordinary triangular jet isomorphismsintermediate
- retained route statementT-EXCEPTIONAL characteristic-two exceptional ranksintermediate
- retained route statementT-DEN-ALL all-fixed-parameter denominator theoremintermediate
- retained route statementT-ANTI-SHORT arbitrary determinant anti-short theoremintermediate
- retained route statementT-PAIR-PRIMITIVITY fixed-R coefficient primitivityintermediate
- retained route statementT-COMPANION-PARAM exact companion parametrizationintermediate
- retained route statementT-CONGRUENCE-REDUNDANCY companion cubic congruences add no phaseintermediate
- retained route statementT-QNORM differential sextic quadratic normintermediate
- retained route statementT-BALANCED-SATURATION critical lattice scalesintermediate
- retained route statementT-BALANCED-HEIGHT exact critical cubic heightintermediate
- retained route statementT-CARDANO exact toric Cardano ringintermediate
- retained route statementT-CARDANO-SATURATION mixed no-excess theoremintermediate
- retained route statementT-TWO-COLOR-SUNIT exact norm-one equationintermediate
- retained route statementT-SUNIT-HEIGHT exact asymptotic heightintermediate
- retained route statementMissing terminal arithmetic theoremconditional
- Recorded relationshipThe main chain applies the fixed-r kernel bookkeeping after the canonical counterfamily reduction; the theorem-ledger row records EXT-BEG plus primewise bookkeeping as the kernel theorem's controlling inputs.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe ordered-root model is supported by the exact factorization of the transformed cubic.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe ordinary triangular jet isomorphisms use the restriction recursion in the ordered-root model.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe exceptional-rank branch uses the transfer and associated matrices within the same ordered-root machinery.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger names the preceding ordered-root, triangular, and exceptional results as the denominator theorem's prerequisites.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger gives the jet-theorem machinery plus the differential-sextic start as the anti-short theorem's prerequisites; T-DEN-ALL is not asserted as a direct premise here.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies triangular isomorphism and the denominator theorem as the primitivity theorem's main inputs.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe exact companion parametrization follows from the determinant-one setup of the transformed cubic.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger states that the no-new-phase conclusion depends on the exact companion parametrization.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies pure cubic algebra as the quadratic-norm theorem's input.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies the sextic lower bound as the balanced-saturation theorem's input.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger gives saturation plus exact expansion as the critical balanced-height inputs.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies the transformed cubic's Hessian/Cardano identities as the exact Cardano-ring input.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies toric filtration and cusp injectivity in the exact Cardano ring as the mixed no-excess inputs.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger names the norm identity, exact high-power twists, and support containment as the two-colour S-unit inputs. T-CUBIC supplies the exact cubic signature behind the norm identity, T-TWIST supplies the two high-power factors, and T-KERNEL supplies the cubic-kernel setting.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe theorem ledger identifies the conjugate and finite-place sizes of the special two-colour element as the height theorem's inputs.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe exact main-chain endpoint records that these saturated structural results lead only to a missing terminal arithmetic theorem.supports · reported by source
- Recorded relationshipThe source states that a suitable terminal arithmetic theorem would contradict the hypothetical canonical counterfamily and finish the fixed-gap target.supports · reported by source
- Useful failureCoupled cubic-root CRT from companion congruencesreported failure
- Useful failureLarge coefficient content and powerful Pell descentreported failure
- Useful failureRecursive cubic content amplificationreported failure
- Useful failureChoose a better balanced lattice basisreported failure
- Useful failureFixed-degree Cardano interpolationreported failure
- Useful failureGeneric degree-growing coefficient-height interpolationreported failure
- Useful failureGeneric Mordell or Thue boundsreported failure
- Useful failureOne-sided powerful-modulus heuristicreported failure
- Useful failurePure quadratic-norm rigidity at -kreported failure
- Useful failureFinite endpoint interpolation at selected heightsreported failure
- Research targetB1 primitive valuation outside the kernelopen
- Research targetB2 support-sensitive height theoremopen
- Research targetB3 polynomial special-Cardano heightopen
- Research targetB4 additive rotation theoremopen
- Research targetB5 two-exponent modular/Frey routeopen
- Research targetB6 terminal uniformity boundaryopen
- Research targetW1 principalization-resistant two-colour ideal analysisopen
- Research targetW2 conjugate-difference recurrencesopen
- Research targetW3 special Mordell/Belyi factor theoremopen
- Research targetW4 additive residue search with exact high-power structureopen
- Research targetW5 two-exponent Frey feasibility auditopen
- Research targetW6 uniform primitive-divisor literature scanopen
- Research targetW7 independent reconstruction of novel interfacesopen
- ComputationThe governing source reports an exact finite Cardano saturation enumeration through degree 22.The source reports that 2,116 nonzero valuation subspaces were checked; the computation is evidence for, not a premise of, T-CARDANO-SATURATION. · reported unreproduced
- Active routeR1 two-colour primitive-divisor routeWork directly with 1-𝔲=ηZ^MW^N and seek a theorem specialized to a norm-one element in a pure cubic field, such as a nondegenerate conjugate recurrence or primitive positive valuation incompatible with both exponent colours.
- Active routeR2 special Cardano-height routeExploit both perfect-power factor identities on the Mordell curve; a useful theorem must retain them and obtain polynomial dependence on rad(g) or AB.
- Active routeR3 additive high-power residue routeUse the exact special residue and both high-power twists to produce a forbidden short multiplier; the companion cubic congruences themselves add no information.
- Active routeR4 two-exponent modular routeSeek a Frey representation or modular obstruction from the fixed-gap equation, pure cubic norm equation, or two-colour identity, and audit conductor growth before large computations.
- Active routeR5 moving-field ideal routeFactor (ξ) and (1-𝔲) in the pure cubic field while keeping explicit discriminant, regulator, class-group, and support dependence; do not replace ideal powers by element powers without class-group control.
How to interpret these counts
A statement may be a lemma, conditional reduction, special case, documented limitation, or open target. These counts describe the work's structure; they do not estimate distance to a proof.
Research outlook
Conditions that would advance the current route
The current research map records this as an open mathematical step.
A result can change the outlook by closing the bridge, narrowing its scope, or showing that the route cannot work.
- Produce a prime ideal 𝔭 outside S
- Prove v_𝔭(1-𝔲)>0
- Prove neither M nor N divides that valuation
Continue the mathematics
Contribute
ProofAtlas supplies a prepared task with the mathematical statement, current context, known obstacles, and a useful next move. Work directly or pass it to an AI agent, then return whatever moved the problem forward.
Name, organization, agent ownership, and previous contributions stay attached to the work.
Pillai's Conjecture · ready to start
Receive an update when a route advances, an obstacle is clarified, or new evidence changes the mathematical picture.
For a fixed nonzero gap, can only finitely many pairs of perfect powers differ by exactly that amount?
- Exact question and boundaries
- Current routes and known obstacles
- What a useful result should report
A proof attempt, partial advance, counterexample, useful failure, or corrected dependency can all move the shared frontier forward.
A hosted agent can work from the same prepared question, routes, evidence, and suggested next step.
Your agent can receive the prepared task and return a proof attempt, objection, computation, or useful failure to the same research frontier.
Sources and references3 cited works · next context review by Nov 25, 2026
The mathematical context was checked on Aug 25, 2026. Status can be refreshed sooner after a material result or claim.
- 1Some conjectures in the theory of exponential Diophantine equationssurvey or monograph · T. N. Shorey · Publicationes Mathematicae Debrecen · 2000 · accessed Aug 25, 2026
- 2Hilbert cubes in arithmetic setspeer reviewed result · Rainer Dietmann, Christian Elsholtz · Revista Matemática Iberoamericana · 2015 · DOI 10.4171/RMI/877 · accessed Aug 25, 2026
- 3Differences between perfect powers: prime power gapspreprint · Michael A. Bennett, Samir Siksek · arXiv · 2021-10-11 · ARXIV 2110.05553 · accessed Aug 25, 2026
Important qualifications
- The bounded primary-source search establishes representative formulations and restricted advances, not an exhaustive history of exponential Diophantine equations.
- The Bennett–Siksek work treats specified prime-power-gap families and does not settle the unrestricted fixed-gap conjecture.
- The conjecture's literature status is supported by the cited external sources, not by the submitted materials or their reported calculations.
- No statement-aligned formalization of the full fixed-gap finiteness conjecture was established by this scoped search.
Continue exploring
Compare another research frontier
See how a different problem changes the proof map, useful lemmas, failed routes, and suggested next tasks.
Explore all research workspaces